AS I WRITE THIS EDITORIAL, I CAN HEAR THE
chants of the Occupy Wall Street demonstrators
outside of my office. In fact, my colleagues and
I have heard the cacophony of protesters’ rants,
whistles, drums and, yes, vuvuzulas several times
a day for the past few weeks.
When they first showed up, most of us thought
it was a fleeting thing—just a bunch of kids with
nothing better to do. But as time passed, what began as a march against
“The Man” turned into a nationwide movement, a rebellion against every-
thing from corporate greed and unfair taxation to unemployment, foreclo-
sures and labor-union disagreements.
Their central complaint, loosely, is that big business and the wealthiest
1% of the country have an unfair influence over US laws and policies. They
want to raise taxes on corporations and the rich; protect Medicare, Social
Security and other public-welfare programs; create more jobs; and abolish
the World Bank and Federal Reserve; among other demands.
The protest has attracted sympathetic celebrities—including filmmaker
Michael Moore, mogul Russell Simmons and rapper Kanye West—as well as
politicians embracing the movement to gain favor at the polls. (The irony is that
many of those supporters are members of the 1% they’re griping about.)
Through weeks of protests, however, most of us have yet to see a clear
point. In fact, a lot of these protestors seem to be missing the point. They’re
all rallying against a system that’s so vast and intricate that they themselves
are likely part of it. After all, without borrowers clamoring for funds, the mortgage market wouldn’t have gotten as inflated as it did. It’s the same for
credit cards. Yes, the cost of living has increased while paychecks haven’t,
but Americans are also notorious for living beyond their means.
They say we need social and economic equality. That’s a noble idea, but
this disparity has always existed. Some rail against capitalism, but we all see
how well socialism worked out for other countries. And I’d be willing to say
that of those protesters pointing their fingers at Wall Street, a good number
of them wouldn’t turn down a well-paying job there, either.
Was Wall Street reckless with financial structures and lending practices?
Absolutely. Is it fair that they’re getting richer while America is getting poorer? Probably not. Was it illegal? No. Big business didn’t create the loopholes
and lax regulation that allowed them to run amok. Think about it. If you let a
kid loose in a candy store without holding his hand, you’re going to have to
deal with an upset stomach and a sugar high later.
No, this movement should have been cast as “Occupy Capitol Hill.” That’s
where all the action is. That’s where elected officials are choosing to support
the interests of lobbyists and corporations, rather than representing their constituents. That’s where politicos are quibbling over budget talks and cutting
corners at the expense of the middle and lower classes. But that seems to
be lost on these protesters. And even more sad is when New York magazine
asked those gathered Downtown whether they voted in the midterm elections, more than half (55%) admitted they did not. So who’s to blame?
OWS is being compared to the Arab Spring movement. While ambitious,
I think that’s a stretch. This movement could go either way—it could provoke
change and gather even more momentum, or it could lose steam and peter
out. I’d put my money on the latter.
Sule Aygoren Carranza
6 REAL ESTATE FORUM SEPTEMBER 2011 6 REAL ESTATE FORUM OCTOBER 2011
America’s Premier Real Estate Business Magazine
Vice President & Group Publisher
Michael G. Desiato
Content Director Publisher
John Salustri Gregg W. Christensen
Editor-in-Chief Sule Aygoren Carranza, email@example.com
Managing Editor Paul Bubny, firstname.lastname@example.org
East Coast Carl Gaines, email@example.com; Northeast Jacqueline
Hlavenka, firstname.lastname@example.org; Southeast Jennifer LeClaire,
email@example.com; Southwest Amy Wolff Sorter, awsorter@alm.
com; Midwest & Global Robert Carr, firstname.lastname@example.org; West Coast
Natalie Dolce, email@example.com
Art Director Nick Koutoufas, firstname.lastname@example.org; Production
Manager Evelyn Fernandez, email@example.com
Editor John Salustri, firstname.lastname@example.org; Custom Content
Manager Ian Ritter, email@example.com; Webmaster Christopher
Sponsorships Daniel Ceniceros, firstname.lastname@example.org; Conference
Producers Jason Young, Kim Last, Colleen McShane
Senior VP, Sales Gregg W. Christensen; VP, Strategic Development
Daniel Ceniceros; Associate Publisher, New Jersey/Mid-Atlantic
Jen McCabe; Online Sales Executive Donald O’Keefe
VP, Integrated Marketing & Sales Development Scott Thompson,
email@example.com; Manager, Reprints, Custom Publishing/
Licensing Alexa Faulkner; Online Marketing Coordinator Teresa
Thaler; Online Advertising Coordinator Kamicia Bass; Associate
Art Director Ysis James; Business Directories Elaine Forchin,
firstname.lastname@example.org; List Rentals Danny Grubert, 914.925.2449
email@example.com; Executive Assistants Natalie
Hall, Madina Wilson
HOW TO REACH REAL ESTATE FORUM
120 Broadway, 5th Floor, New York, NY 10271
Tel: 212.457.9400 Fax: 646.822.5365
SUBSCRIPTIONS & BACK ISSUES & REPRINTS
Call 410.571.5893 or log on to: www.reforum.com/subscribe
or log on to: www.remreprints.com
Digital editions of each issue of Real Estate Forum are now
available at www.globest.com/reforum. To view or download our 2011
Media Guide, visit www.reforum.com.
ALM Senior Management
William L. Pollak President/CEO, Allison C. Hoffman SVP/Chief Legal Officer,
Eric F. Lundberg SVP/Chief Financial Officer, Kevin H. Michielsen, SVP/
Information & Research Solutions, Kevin J. Vermeulen SVP/Legal Media,
Jeffrey K. Whittle SVP/Chief Technology Officer, Michael G. Desiato VP/ Real
Estate Media, Sara Diamond VP/Information Solutions, Stephen Lincoln, VP/
Regional Businesses, Aric Press, VP/Editor-in-Chief
ALM, an Integrated Media Company, is a leading provider of news and information for the legal and commercial real estate markets. ALM’s market-leading
brands include The American Lawyer, Corporate Counsel, GlobeSt.com, Insight
Conferences, Law.com, Law Journal Press, Legal Tech, The National Law Journal
and Real Estate Forum. Learn more about ALM, visit www.alm.com.
Real Estate Forum® is a registered trademark of ALM Media Properties LLC